Keywords. CASP, MiFID license, MiFID II, investment firm, tokenized financial instruments, crypto derivatives.
The MiCA Regulation created a harmonized European license for crypto-asset service providers (CASPs). That license, however, does not cover everything a CASP may want to offer: as soon as a crypto-asset qualifies as a financial instrument, it falls outside MiCA and under MiFID II. For a CASP, obtaining a MiFID license can therefore be the next step to broaden its offering.
There is no shortcut. While MiCA allows certain already authorized financial entities to provide crypto-asset services through a simple notification, no equivalent mechanism exists in the other direction. A CASP wishing to obtain a MiFID license must follow the ordinary authorization procedure applicable to investment firms.
The use of blockchain technology does not, in itself, determine the regulatory regime applicable to an asset. ESMA recalls the principle of technological neutrality: the tokenization of a financial instrument does not change its legal qualification.
A share, a bond or a unit in a collective investment undertaking therefore remains a financial instrument when it is issued or represented in the form of a token. Services provided on these tokens fall under MiFID II, not under the CASP license.
The same reasoning applies to derivatives. The qualification of a derivative is distinct from that of its underlying: a crypto-asset falling under MiCA may serve as the underlying of a derivative falling under MiFID II. Certain futures, options, swaps or perpetual contracts on crypto-assets may thus require a MiFID license, whatever the regime of the underlying.
For a CASP, the interest is very concrete. A MiFID license may make it possible to:
Depending on the services actually provided, the CASP will have to hold the corresponding authorizations.
In France, the MiFID license corresponds to the authorization as an investment firm, which confers the status of investment services provider (PSI) for the services covered. The authorization specifies each investment service authorized, for example:
Capital requirements depend on the services applied for. The minimum initial capital ranges from €75,000 for firms that do not hold client funds or financial instruments to €750,000 for dealing on own account or underwriting, in addition to ongoing prudential requirements.
The authorization is granted by the Autorité de contrôle prudentiel et de résolution (ACPR), after approval of the programme of operations by the Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF).
The application must in particular set out the shareholding structure, the governance, the senior managers and key function holders, the resources devoted to the project and the organization planned for each investment service applied for.
The programme of operations is central. It must cover each investment service applied for and describe the activities envisaged, their organization and the way they will be provided. In practice, the file must consistently reflect the product offered, the clients targeted, the services applied for and the organization put in place to provide them.
These periods do not cover the whole project. Preparing the file can itself take several months, and the exchanges needed to reach completeness must be anticipated. In practice, an overall timeline of nine to twelve months can reasonably be envisaged, depending on the maturity of the project, the quality of the initial file and the exchanges with the authorities.
Depending on the project, other routes may be considered before or instead of a full MiFID license:
Each route has its own constraints in terms of control of the client relationship, liability and economics. The choice is best made at the structuring stage of the project.
No. Tokenized shares, bonds or fund units remain financial instruments and fall under MiFID II. Providing services on them requires the corresponding MiFID authorization or an authorized partner.
No. The notification procedure provided by MiCA only works in the other direction, for certain financial entities wishing to provide crypto-asset services. A CASP must follow the ordinary investment firm authorization procedure.
The ACPR decides within a maximum of six months from receipt of a complete file. Including the preparation of the file and the exchanges with the authorities, an overall timeline of nine to twelve months is a reasonable estimate.
Not necessarily. A derivative is qualified independently of its underlying. A future, option or perpetual contract on a crypto-asset may be a financial instrument under MiFID II, even though the underlying crypto-asset falls under MiCA.
Related pages: MiFID and Investment Firms Lawyer · CASP Authorization Lawyer (MiCA) · Contact Daniel Arroche
The information contained in this article is provided for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. It does not purport to be exhaustive and must be assessed in the light of the circumstances specific to each situation, in particular the business model, the services envisaged and the applicable regulatory framework. It is recommended to seek appropriate legal advice before taking any decision based on the elements presented in this article.